Bernstein: OpenAI launches ChatGPT wallet, AI payment competition reaches a new inflection point; Visa (V.US) and Mastercard (MA.US) are expected to become big winners.

date
23:54 16/11/2026
avatar
GMT Eight
As AI agents gradually evolve from information query tools into personal assistants capable of autonomously completing shopping and payments, the global payments industry is ushering in new competitive opportunities.
As artificial intelligence (AI) agents gradually evolve from information query tools into personal assistants capable of autonomously completing shopping and payments, the global payments industry is ushering in new competitive opportunities. In a research report released on November 13, Bernstein analyst Harshita Rawat and her team noted that OpenAI's launch of the ChatGPT wallet and its choice to partner with traditional card payment networks marks an important step forward in the development of the AI agent payments ecosystem. Visa (V.US) and Mastercard (MA.US) are expected to occupy a favorable position in this emerging market by virtue of payment token technology and mature transaction security systems. Bernstein currently rates Visa and Mastercard "Outperform" with price targets of US$486 and US$764, respectively. On November 13, OpenAI announced the launch of the ChatGPT wallet, a product developed by OpenAI in partnership with Visa, Mastercard and American Express Company (AXP.US). Initially, it will be made available to US ChatGPT Pro users aged 18 and over through Dots, a personal AI agent service. Eligible users need only enter their card information once; thereafter, each time a user authorizes an AI agent to make a purchase, the relevant card payment network will provide a dedicated payment token to complete the transaction without disclosing the user's actual card information to the AI agent. This payment method not only protects users' card information but also preserves benefits within the existing card payment system such as transaction dispute resolution and spending rewards. OpenAI expects that as the relevant technology matures, users will in the future be able to fully delegate shopping tasks to AI agents after setting conditions such as clear spending limits and time restrictions, while retaining corresponding authorization records. Because the ChatGPT wallet uses payment tokens provided by card payment networks, it is compatible with merchants' existing checkout processes. OpenAI is also working with fraud prevention providers such as Forter, Riskified, Sardine and Signifyd, as well as payment service providers such as Adyen, Checkout.com and Stripe, to help merchants identify legitimate transactions initiated by AI agents. Bernstein believes that the ChatGPT wallet's use of token technology from card payment networks is of significant strategic importance to Visa and Mastercard. The firm noted that although AI agent shopping is still at a very early stage of development, with actual transaction volumes negligible, the development of the relevant technology has reached an inflection point. With the successive launch of consumer-grade AI agents such as Meta's Muse, the payments industry is competing over how future AI shopping transactions will be processed. At present, no unified standard has yet formed in the AI agent payments market. Banks, merchants and internet platforms are taking different approaches, including blocking transactions initiated by AI agents, selectively opening payment permissions, establishing partnerships with AI platforms, and launching their own AI agent services. Meanwhile, some AI agents complete transactions through temporary solutions such as one-time virtual cards rather than payment tokens designed specifically for AI agents. Bernstein noted that Mastercard had previously stated clearly on an earnings call that one-time virtual cards such as those used by Muse are not a long-term solution for AI agent shopping, because such payment methods may sever the link between transactions and consumers' existing spending rewards and payment controls. Mastercard therefore does not support such temporary payment solutions and instead hopes to drive industry adoption of payment technology designed specifically for AI agents. Bernstein believes that although achieving all AI agent transactions through payment tokens still requires further improvement across the entire payments ecosystem, Visa and Mastercard are actively working with industry participants to ensure that temporary solutions such as virtual cards serve only as a transitional measure. In addition, card payment networks can leverage mechanisms such as transaction liability allocation to encourage banks, merchants and AI platforms to adopt their payment tokens, thereby further consolidating their position in the AI payments market. Bernstein emphasized that the significance of Visa and Mastercard competing for the AI agent payment token market lies not only in ensuring that future AI shopping transactions continue to be completed through card payment networks. More importantly, once their payment tokens are widely adopted, the two companies are expected to be able to provide more value-added services to AI platforms, merchants and other payments industry participants through these tokens, thereby opening up new sources of revenue growth. Citing Stripe's current charging model for shared payment tokens as an example, the firm noted that payment tokens themselves have potential commercialization value, and card payment networks can further expand services in the future around areas such as transaction security, identity verification and risk management. Under an optimistic scenario, if transactions initiated by AI agents were to account for a mid-to-high single-digit percentage of overall consumer transactions in the future, the related business could contribute an additional several percentage points to Visa's and Mastercard's growth. However, Bernstein also noted clear differences between the ChatGPT wallet and Meta's Muse in their choice of payment partners. Muse supported Stripe Link and Shop Pay at launch and plans to further integrate PayPal (PYPL.US), whereas the ChatGPT wallet currently relies mainly on payment tokens provided by Visa, Mastercard and American Express Company and does not appear to include other third-party digital wallets. Bernstein believes that while OpenAI may still bring in more digital wallet partners in the future, the current product design may also reflect OpenAI's intention to establish its own strategic position in the consumer payments segment, similar to how Apple Inc.'s (AAPL.US) Apple Pay did not integrate other digital wallets for a considerable period. The firm noted that digital wallets such as PayPal and Shop Pay still have certain strategic opportunities in the consumer-grade AI agent market. For example, if AI agent platforms struggle to find an effective commercialization model, digital wallets may be able to play a greater role by leveraging their existing user base and payment service capabilities. However, the window of time for these companies to seize market opportunities may be relatively limited. Although Bernstein is optimistic about the long-term development potential of AI agent payments, the firm emphasized that the actual transaction volume of AI agent shopping remains extremely small, and technological maturity and consumer trust remain important factors constraining the industry's development. For example, Uber Technologies, Inc. (UBER.US) previously disclosed that of approximately 320 million delivery and ride-hailing transactions during Halloween week, only 504 were completed by AI agents. A recent shopping capability test conducted by Visa on mainstream AI models also showed that in tests simulating real shopping scenarios, the AI models evaluated had an overall pass rate of only 57.2%, and consistency of performance still needs improvement. More notably, among tasks that failed the test, about 54% still ultimately resulted in actual purchase behavior. Bernstein believes this means AI agents still need significant improvement in shopping decisions and execution accuracy, and also signals that transaction disputes, refunds and returns may become major challenges facing the AI agent shopping market in the future. This is precisely an area where traditional card payment networks have an advantage. After decades of development, Visa and Mastercard have established mature mechanisms for transaction dispute resolution, consumer protection and risk management, and are expected to extend these capabilities to AI agent payment scenarios. Bernstein noted that the involvement of AI agents in transactions will significantly increase the complexity of the payment process, and whether consumers trust AI agents and whether the payments industry can establish effective authorization and governance mechanisms will become key factors determining the pace of development of this market. Therefore, companies capable of providing trusted payment credentials for AI agents and establishing corresponding transaction security and governance rules are expected to gain important competitive advantages in the future payments ecosystem. In addition, Bernstein believes that recently launched AI agent shopping products are still mainly aimed at helping consumers complete shopping tasks more conveniently, rather than directly taking over merchants' payment processing business or becoming the actual seller in transactions. If AI platforms wish to further control merchants' checkout processes, they will face many complex issues, including real-time price and inventory synchronization, application of promotional offers and membership rewards, order fulfillment, after-sales service and cross-merchant shopping. This means that even if AI agents gradually become an important entry point for consumer shopping, existing payment networks and payment service providers are still expected to play an important role in transaction execution. Looking ahead, Bernstein will focus on the actual pace of integration of AI agent payment technology by issuing banks and merchants, the penetration of AI agent shopping during the year-end shopping season, and whether more internet platforms will establish partnerships with card payment networks. Among these, whether Alphabet Inc. Class C (GOOGL.US) and Meta's (META.US) Muse will adopt payment tokens designed specifically for AI agents in the future, and how Financial Institutions, Inc. such as American Express Company and JPMorgan's (JPM.US) Chase Bank develop their own AI agent services, will become important indicators for observing the industry's competitive landscape. From an investment perspective, in addition to Visa and Mastercard, Bernstein also rates payment service provider Adyen, buy-now-pay-later provider Affirm (AFRM.US) and fintech company Block (XYZ.US) "Outperform," while rating PayPal, Fiserv (FISV.US), Global Payments (GPN.US) and Klarna (KLAR.US) "Market Perform." Based on the closing price on November 12, Visa's US$486 price target implies potential upside of about 15.6%, while Mastercard's US$764 price target implies potential upside of about 17.1%.